🏠 Home 🔍 Search 🎲 Pools 📊 Statistics 🏆 Hall of Fame
← Back to Search

Loading…

—
Obj. Avg
—
Personal
—
Final
0
Ratings
Scoring rules: Each category is scored 0.0–10.0 (one decimal). 0.0 = absolute worst — you may award this once per category, ever. 10.0 = absolute peak — same restriction. 5.0 ≠ average — it means "mid". The distinction matters.
Formula: Objective avg = sum of all 10 categories ÷ 10. Final = (Objective avg + Personal score) ÷ 2.
—
Objective avg
—
Personal
—
Final score
( — + — ) ÷ 2 = —

Objective Rating

10 categories · averaged
👥 Characters
Main Character 0.0
Character design Goals & motivation Quirk / humanity Root factor Development & backstory
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Main Cast 0.0
Visual design Synergy with MC Fodder vs growth
012345678910
Side Cast 0.0
Impression (even with 2 lines) Characters have actual lives
012345678910
Antagonists 0.0
Mirror / contrast to MC Block / resistance quality Own goal & motivation
012345678910
Characters subtotal 0.0 / 10.0
📖 Story
Introduction 0.0
Hook in first chapters Show don't tell Inciting incident World orientation
012345678910
Theme 0.0
Story summarized early Ending answers the opening Real-world connection Theme in subtext (not spoon-fed)
012345678910
Plot 0.0
But/Therefore driven (not "and then") Twists & surprises
012345678910
Setting 0.0
Internal logic & rules (no rules = no stakes) Sensory details & vibe World-building continuity & direction
012345678910
Art 0.0
Clarity Character acting Panel composition & eye-flow Reflects story & emotion Scenery · effects · details
012345678910
Other (genre-specific) 0.0
Power system Love interests Unique genre elements
012345678910
Story subtotal 0.0 / 10.0
Objective Average
Sum of all 10 categories ÷ 10
0.0

Personal Rating

gut feeling · after completion

Rate this immediately after finishing — on instinct, without overthinking. Be honest. Justification is required.

Personal Score 0.0
012345678910
Required to submit. No justification = no submission. 0 chars

Written Review (optional)

Write an overall explanation of your rating — what worked, what didn't, and why you feel this way about the work.

Optional. Will appear publicly alongside your rating. 0 chars
Final Score
( 0.0 + 0.0 ) ÷ 2 = 0.0
Objective avg + Personal score, then ÷ 2
0.0
/10
Community Ratings
0 ratings
📊
No ratings yet
Be the first to rate this work. Data here will power statistics & AI prediction.